HESI Workshop on “Developing Guidance for Alternatives Assessment”

  • Start Date/Time :
  • End Date/Time :
  • Location : Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, USA
  • Venue : National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences

2013 Developing Guidance Banner


The HESI Frameworks for Alternative Chemical Assessment and Selection of Safer, Sustainable Alternatives Subcommittee (a.k.a. Sustainable Alternatives Subcommittee) was initiated in 2011 as an Emerging Issues Subcommittee. Its mission is to evaluate and identify key elements/criteria and tools to help trigger and guide the selection of safer, sustainable alternatives while minimizing the likelihood of regrettable substitutions. The subcommittee is comprised of technical experts from academia, industry, non-profit organizations, and government and has been working towards holding a workshop to develop more detailed guidance for conducting alternatives assessments. Results of the workshop and of the subcommittee will be submitted for publication in a peer reviewed journal.

Workshop Purpose

The purpose of the workshop was to bring together multi-stakeholder, multi-disciplinary expertise to develop practical, problem driven guidance on the conduct of alternatives assessment. To accomplish this, the subcommittee was divided into three subgroups to address three interrelated topics where clear challenges were previously identified. The goal of each subgroup was to lead a multi-stakeholder discussion, that developed useful techniques and guidance documents to enhance existing alternatives assessment frameworks and to identify challenges where further work is needed. The three subgroup topics were:

1) Attributes and Tools

  • Attributes beyond hazard that are also important, including life cycle assessment, exposure, risk, performance, cost and social responsibility
  • New tools for prioritization and assessment of hazard, risk and other attributes

2) Decision-making and Weighing

  • Making decisions with limited data and a minimum data set
  • Best practices for weighing disparate attributes

3) Data gaps

  • What are the data gaps and data needs
  • What are solutions for missing data

Workshop Outline

  • Feb. 7 morning: overview of the project/workshop, presentations by invited speakers
  • Feb. 7 afternoon: concurrent break-out discussion sessions for the 3 subgroups
  • Feb. 8 morning: concurrent break-out discussion sessions for the 3 subgroups
  • Feb. 8 afternoon: reports from break-out sessions, discussion, and next steps

Please click here to download the draft workshop agenda.

Who Should Attend

Workshop participation was by invitation-only and the workshop size is limited to 50. We sought active participation by experts in alternatives assessment, specifically in the three topics described above. The workshop was highly interactive with two half-day break-out sessions for discussions.

Workshop Organizers

  • David Constable, Subgroup 3 Leader (Sustainability Foresights LLC)
  • Darlene Dixon (National Institute of Enviromental Health Sciences)
  • Royce Francis, Subgroup 2 Leader (George Washington University)
  • Derek Muir, Co-chair (Environment Canada)
  • Satinder Sarang, Subgroup 1 Leader (Shell)
  • Pam Spencer, Co-chair (Dow Chemical Company)
  • Jennifer Young (ILSI Health and Environmental Sciences Institute)

For additional information, contact Jennifer Young Tanir: jtanir@hesiglobal.org; (202) 659-3306 x132.

Contact Us

Health and Environmental Sciences Institute (HESI)

Phone: +1-202-659-8404
Fax: +1-202-659-3859

740 15th Street NW, Suite 600
Washington, DC 20005

Stay Informed

Sign up for our monthly e-newsletter.